Avatar – Reviewed By Intellect
My intellect has been begging me to also have its say about Avatar for weeks, so I’m finally, grudgingly, going to give it a little space. After all, it’s hung out with me all these years, and I’m sick of its whining:
“First off the film is manipulative and you fell for it!”
Hold on! Wait a minute, little intellect. It’s a work of art, it’s selective– that’s not manipulative.
“It’s beautiful pictures without reality!”
It’s the realest damn pictures I’ve ever seen, dude!
“Will you let me talk!? It’s a pure appeal to the emotions, beautiful and simplistic. It’s like stupidly falling in love with a beautiful shallow woman!”
Oh, intellect! What do you know– what will you ever know– about falling in love?
”And if you’d listened to me when you did you’d have avoided a hell of a lot of trouble!”
Thank you, Spock.
Okay, look. I loved the film. I don’t apologize for that. But I’m going to now give you one– that’s one– long paragraph– or two short ones– to have your say. Go! Now!
“I can’t do it in that space! I need…”
One long! Two short! Go!
“Pandora is a fantasy world that can never be, and the Na’vi are pure fantasy also, and the way everything is presented is such a fantasy that it’s not worth respecting. The Na’vi aren’t aliens– aliens will probably look like crabs or cockroaches– they’re just exalted human beings, basically idealized Native Americans, who are so supernaturally beautiful and pure both physically and spiritually that I can’t take them seriously as beings. You think this world is realistic? Senses! Senses!? Where are the smells? Where’s the stinks? Where’s the death? Real death, not a few carefully staged plot-advancing movie deaths. They live in a rain forest where it doesn’t rain, they’re surrounded by monsters that never succeed in eating anyone, nobody’s ugly which means they must kill the “inferior” infants the way the Spartans or some Native Americans did, they’re hot-tempered and armed but we never see their wars, they tame flying monsters with ease that in real life would kill half of them…!”
Time’s half up, friend.
“Okay. Okay. Now the humans. The whole deck is stacked against them– us! This is what we’re supposed to believe: We’ve mastered fusion and antimatter power which means we have infinite energy already, our biogenetic technology is so advanced we can create actual bodies and then our science is so magical we can transfer minds between bodies which is a more spectacular trick than beaming up on Star Trek. So how about a little awe for the humans!? The Na’vi aren’t the only magic ones here. Yet we’re supposed to also believe that a civilization this advanced still wants or needs to tear up another world to get at some minerals! And that back home Earth isn’t prospering it’s dying! And a single corporation is given this world to loot! And back home a few corporations are doing the same to Earth! That’s nuts! There isn’t a single mention of government in the entire film. Any government. I thought Cameron was shallow before, but this is zero-dimensional– even in Imax! You’d never accept this kind of shallowness in a book or play, so why do…!?”
Time’s up, intellect. Thank you. Let me call you Intellect.
_____________________________________________________________
So look how impotent the intellect is. It says this can’t be and that can’t be– but they all are. In a work of art, a creation with its own rules. If you don’t like it build your own! I can see it now. But how come nobody wants to spend three hours with it?
_____________________________________________________________
“Ah, I got to you a little, didn’t I?”
